What gets me is the judge's answer at the end. The man on trial had already admitted, under questioning, that he put something in her wine without telling her, and the judge's response is the part that sticks. Before any of that, the woman told the court how it started: they met at the shop where she works, he asked for her number, then invited her to dinner and she agreed. After dinner came the invitation to his hotel. She said yes to going, but once he started touching her she told him straight that she wasn't interested in sex. He stopped at first. Then he poured her another glass of wine, and not long after she started feeling strange, her body reacting in ways she couldn't understand while her judgment went cloudy. His account was that she wanted him, that she was the one who eventually initiated everything, and he denied ever forcing her. The prosecutor walked him through it: did agreeing to dinner, walking into his hotel room and later appearing sexually responsive add up to consent in his mind? He said exactly that. But forensic testing found a substance in her system consistent with drug-facilitated sexual assault. Hotel cameras showed him handling her drink while she was in the bathroom, and investigators recovered a container of the same substance from his belongings. The defence objected that none of this established what was in her mind; the judge overruled and told the prosecutor to continue. Asked directly whether he put anything in her wine, the man went silent. Asked again whether he drugged her because she refused to sleep with him, he said he just wanted her to relax and didn't think it was a big deal. The judge then asked whether he had administered a substance without her knowledge after she had expressly refused sexual contact. Yes, Your Honor, he said, but she didn't resist afterwards. That's where the judge drew the line: a person's physical response is not proof of consent, and neither is going into a hotel room, taking a drink, or saying yes to dinner. She agreed to accompany him. She did not agree to be drugged. The prosecutor added that her earlier refusal had been clear. The court found the defendant guilty of sexual assault, with the judge stating that the evidence showed he had purposefully compromised her capacity to make a free and informed decision. His last protest was that she never said no the second time. The judge's reply: she had already said no, and he took away her ability to choose freely.
4d
What gets me is the judge's answer at the end. The man on trial had already admitted, under questioning, that he put something in her wine without telling her, and the judge's response is the part that sticks. Before any of that, the woman told the court how it started: they met at the shop where she works, he asked for her number, then invited her to dinner and she agreed. After dinner came the invitation to his hotel. She said yes to going, but once he started touching her she told him straight that she wasn't interested in sex. He stopped at first. Then he poured her another glass of wine, and not long after she started feeling strange, her body reacting in ways she couldn't understand while her judgment went cloudy. His account was that she wanted him, that she was the one who eventually initiated everything, and he denied ever forcing her. The prosecutor walked him through it: did agreeing to dinner, walking into his hotel room and later appearing sexually responsive add up to consent in his mind? He said exactly that. But forensic testing found a substance in her system consistent with drug-facilitated sexual assault. Hotel cameras showed him handling her drink while she was in the bathroom, and investigators recovered a container of the same substance from his belongings. The defence objected that none of this established what was in her mind; the judge overruled and told the prosecutor to continue. Asked directly whether he put anything in her wine, the man went silent. Asked again whether he drugged her because she refused to sleep with him, he said he just wanted her to relax and didn't think it was a big deal. The judge then asked whether he had administered a substance without her knowledge after she had expressly refused sexual contact. Yes, Your Honor, he said, but she didn't resist afterwards. That's where the judge drew the line: a person's physical response is not proof of consent, and neither is going into a hotel room, taking a drink, or saying yes to dinner. She agreed to accompany him. She did not agree to be drugged. The prosecutor added that her earlier refusal had been clear. The court found the defendant guilty of sexual assault, with the judge stating that the evidence showed he had purposefully compromised her capacity to make a free and informed decision. His last protest was that she never said no the second time. The judge's reply: she had already said no, and he took away her ability to choose freely.
4d
Ancora nessun commento. Sii il primo!
Commenti
Ancora nessun commento. Sii il primo!